Thoroughly Good blog.thoroughlygood.me

BBC Proms 2026

Review – BBC Proms 2026: Rachmaninov’s Second Symphony

Nadia Boulanger’s Fantasy for piano and orchestra is an interesting demonstration, and Rachmaninov’s second symphony a solid read.

Jon Jacob 6 August 2026

Programme

Ravel orch. Colin Matthews Le vallee des cloches
Nadia Boulanger Fantasy for piano and orchestra
Rachmaninov Symphony No. 2 in E minor

Alexandra Dariescus (piano)
Halle
Conductor: Kahchun Wong

Wednesday 5 August · 6.00pm – Royal Albert Hall

BBC Sounds

Preview

Biased view incoming. Rachmaninov’s Second Symphony is the finest of all symphonies — in its mastery of melody, its emotional immediacy, its expression, and ultimately both its likability and its enduring popularity. Listening to it is to appreciate the work of a craftsman: its cohesion both in large-scale structure and in melodic construction, as though you’ve taken delivery of a handmade piece of furniture and must delay moving it into position while you admire the joinery. Follow the emotional journey and there will come a point when the eyes start watering. Others may feel no choice but to blub uncontrollably in the corner.

A tempestuous first movement lays the ground for a fast-paced second. The third movement contains one of the greatest clarinet solos in the repertoire — bittersweet yearning taken to new heights. The concluding movement counters all of that heart-on-sleeve intensity with joyous celebration. Someone has been reunited with something they thought they’d lost, and we’re all quite relieved to learn that. Grab your nearest box of absorbent tissues. You should, if the Halle come good, need them.

Review

Rarely does music elicit quite such a strong reaction. There will be plenty of others who will no doubt have summoned a great many positively-intended adjectives to advocate for Nadia Boulanger’s (Fantaisie variée) Fantasy for piano and orchestra. I want to admire the work – I feel as though I ought to – but it feels like a first draft rather than a final one. There are moments of interestingness. In a lot of places the harmonic choices are more interesting than the melodic. There are sequences that sound cohesive, followed by others that feel awkward and underdeveloped. Pianist Alexandra Dariescu is undoubtedly the right advocate for the work – her commitment in building awareness ahead of the concert is unequivocal. It’s interesting. It’s entertaining. It also feels like an extremely demanding work to pull together.

Rachmaninov’s Symphony No. 2 is a key work for me (see the preview for more detail on that). It’s the soundtrack of the early days of my longest relationship. My partner and I met on a blind date in late ‘97, and bonded over a love of listening to music, something that built on a listening strategy discovered at university only a few years before. I vividly recall proposing the idea of marriage when we listened to Rachmaninov’s second symphony (I was introducing the ‘best solo in classical music’ to him whilst our minds had been altered by something or other). Such is the backstory; it’s hard not to expect the world from every single performance of the work.

The Hallé’s performance under Kahchun Wong was conscientious. Cautious, perhaps. The first movement was heartfelt. Well-meant, sometimes veering on the heavy-handed. Different melodic lines needed to be more nimble. There were moments when the love interest was shifting around on a Zimmer frame and possibly supported by over-engineered breathing apparatus. The conclusion to the first movement was resolute, but might have had a little more impetus. In contrast, the second movement’s prompt pace was welcome, though the close-in mics for the glock threatened to expose a momentarily misaligned ensemble. The strings nailed it in the contrasting romantic expanse, making light work of the shameless slides. The fugue saw things tighten, with an unexpected Tchaikovsky feel to proceedings in places (the legato lines were interesting though took a bit of getting used to). When the tempo suddenly ramped up, it appeared one or two at the back of the section were caught by surprise. The third movement brought the desired emotion – watery eyes, trembling bottom lip, the lot – but didn’t quite have the hazy heat I’ve come to expect from other live performances. The final movement was the most successful, throwaway detail in the string lines given more prominence than normal, making the interplay between strings, wind and brass feel almost like fireworks in places. An exhilarating conclusion to a solid read that improved movement by movement.

This review will be updated in due course.

Gallery

© Jon Jacob / Thoroughly Good https://blog.thoroughlygood.me/2026/08/06/review-bbc-proms-2026-rachmaninovs-second/