Review
Classical music’s supposed barrier to entry isn’t its tradition, but our fractured attention spans. While the industry hides behind self-referential marketing and smartphone screens, true connection requires the one thing modern culture avoids: the willingness to surrender our attention to long-form live experience.
Multiple images have been on repeat in my head the past week or so. Compulsive thinking does that. One after another. Over and over again. Like flicking through a photo album in search of a picture that isn’t there.
The first image is from the Prom I bought a ticket for last Monday, bought off the back of the Swedish Chamber Orchestra concert the day before; such was the influence that feeling connected with the audience had over my willingness to reach for my credit card. For the Monday night concert, I’d opted for one of the back row choir seats to see conductor Ryan Bancroft in his swansong appearance in a programme of Copland and Stravinsky. There was much in this outing for the BBC NOW that compensated for the orchestra’s last one. Stravinsky’s Petrushka as a work outshone that which went before and it showed in the playing. Copland’s Billy the Kid was perky, though the Clarinet Concerto Anthony McGill premiered was a bit of a damp squib: heavy on the vibe and light on development. Nonetheless, where a choir seat delivers is the gladiatorial view. From seat 28 I had line of sight of the woodwind, and Bancroft’s easy warmth and trusting batonless beat. In addition, the heartbreaking moment when a technical malfunction resulted in the tuba player missing out on his moment in the Stravinsky and, without the slightest theatricality, him hanging his head as a result. Still, at least Musicians’ Union (and a presumably still robust BBC contract) ensure he still receives his fee.
The pathos of the event was at risk of being diluted because of what was going on in the row in front of me. An audience member sat in the row in front of me chose the moment Bancroft started the Copland to start frantically logging into her work email. Were it not for the woman sat next to me – her granddaughter keeping a keen eye on the percussion section – then we might all of us have spent the first half distracted by whatever it was that was distracting the woman jabbing at her iPhone. Despite insistent silent protestations, little behavioural change was achieved. In a world where doubling down has been made a perfectly acceptable way to respond to guerilla accountability, this wasn’t entirely surprising. I do know who her employer is, though. I also know that she had repeated trouble remembering her password, and what she eventually reset it to.
***
The tube home – our second image – was delayed by a dog on the line somewhere beyond South Ken. Many groans were heard from the platform, slowly occupied by more and more passengers heading eastbound. Emergency measures deployed, I take up position behind the yellow line, soon after which a woman older than me suddenly appears, seemingly shoved into position by her husband behind her. When the train arrives and the doors open, there is a sense of urgency to grab a seat, as though we’re playing musical chairs. It appears I end up alongside her husband, who settles into playing a game on his phone. His wife, still standing, looks around in mild panic, eventually settling in the last remaining seat alongside a woman with a bandaged wrist and a bob who turns to her and says, “You were at the Prom too?” The pair converse. It turns out that the woman with the bandaged wrist only really comes for the atmosphere, so much better than listening on the radio, so she says — and finds it absolutely amazing that we get to see musicians like McGill, what with, as she emotes, his considerable background. All fantastic, apparently. As the train pulled into Westminster and they made a move to leave, I made a mental note to message Proms and Radio 3 chieftain Sam Jackson with my covert audience feedback.
***
I’d passed Sam front of house pre-concert (third image) earlier in the evening. He was walking at pace, attention on his phone, rucksack on his back. We know each other enough for me to say hello. I didn’t. Partly professional instinct — twenty years’ experience of these corridors as a minefield of audience members walking at different paces, or stopping dead still, teaches you not to add to the traffic. But mostly it’s just me — I don’t go looking for people, and I tend to dress that up, after the fact, as courtesy – the mobile phone is a useful or inadvertent signal in certain contexts that we’re busy and can’t be interrupted. Funny thing, walking at pace through the part of the building whose whole job is getting people into the room where attention actually happens. We need to say no to our mobiles more and, in certain situations, make ourselves more visibly available — the audience in the room is more important than the perceived one online.
***
The following night I’m back at the Royal Albert Hall, this time in the Radio 3 commentary box. I’m a guest of the presenter that night – Dr Hannah French – who is reliably as enthusiastic in conversation as she is on air. Authenticity is key. So too knowledge. It is a pleasure to be a guest; twenty years, almost to the day, since I first set foot in this hallowed space. For this evening, the commentary area for Hannah’s night is, owing to the benefit of a flat floor, next door to the commentary box where I sit alone. “Just be aware,” warns Hannah in her wheelchair pre-concert, “you will likely be photographed by members of the audience thinking you’re the presenter.” Suits me fine. Turned out she was right. I was papped twice.

Here then, our fourth image. Watching Shostakovich 10 from the Radio 3 commentary box. It’s like you’re in the orchestra without having to play and not getting paid. You hear everything. The second movement is as directed in the score. One intensely angry outburst. A scream. Rattled off with all of the bile that my mother reserved for those special moments. As the piccolo reverberates and eventually peters out, the timpanist turns and nods knowingly to the percussionist sat behind him. Unbidden, his look secures the moment. This performance. This seat. That look.
I didn’t go back to the Royal Albert Hall after that. The evening was, aside from the music, an unexpectedly overwhelming affair. A former distant BBC colleague and Proms Legend had appeared pre-concert. We reminisced on her extended career and my comparatively brief stint. At the interval I’m leaving the box, and a random voice calls out my name – an old pal from County Youth Orchestra. Haven’t seen him for ten years, twenty years before that at his engagement. He’s since come out. He’s here with his high-achieving offspring and pilot husband. He references his ex-wife. It’s the first time I’ve thought of her in aeons: the same person I studied GCSE Music with forty years ago.
Where the compulsive thinking risks the mind grinding to a migraine-inducing stasis, the fast arrival of previously unthought-of memories feels like a multiple pile up of London buses. It’s all too much to deal with. It’s also the inevitable consequence of what classical does – a small committed audience drawn together by an appetite for nostalgia and a love for the soundtrack that underpins it. Little wonder, amidst this emotional melee, that wine hits the spot. En route to the bar I bump into someone else from the BBC (someone who appeared in a Thoroughly Good piano duet video from nearly twenty years ago). Much air kissing and rubbing of arms ensues.
***
Our fifth image is a montage of social media posts. Well-meant protestations of humility and gratitude designed to capture a special performance moment at the Proms, morphing into earnest promises to demystify classical and make classical music venues more inviting. We are advised that musicians need to promote themselves more and that they can do so more relatably with overstatements of vulnerability. The group pictures in front of the Royal Albert Hall of the artist’s team tell a different story of ritual connection and mutual amplification – as though it’s a wedding we’ve all intended (or not). In documenting the experience, the focus – the performance – is in advertently overshadowed downplayed in favour of a self-referential professionalism. On the other side of town, an artistic director sits in an empty auditorium, failing to answer the question about how concert venues can be more appealing to Gen Z by talking about the historical canon people can experience in the venue. A tiresome straw man, same as ever. This time it just stands there. All this content viewed on my mobile phone which appears to think I still want to see it even though it simply irritates me in the way it fails to represent the world I love.
If the idea of classical is uninviting we might look at the barriers in our hands that distract our attention away from it. We insist on instant connection, but at the cost of something that takes longer to build. Connection demands the audience member’s attention. Attention doesn’t mean knowledge. It means surrender. In a world where our attention is commandeered, those with the loudest voices overlook the escape that long-form live promises. Self-promotion and meaningless statements fill the void. If real-world connection is a difficult experience to advocate for then presumably its because they’ve never allowed themselves the experience in the first place.