Review
A charming new setting of the nativity from the Master of the King’s Music in the church where Noyes Fludde was first performed.
📷 Claire Shovelton
Errollyn Wallen’s A Christmas Miracle – the third collaboration with Mahogany Opera’s Frederic Wake-Walker – is a charming, heartwarming framing of the Christmas story, fresh settings of congregational carols punctuating a descriptive theatrical score.
A large company of young and adult voices from the local community joined forces with a professional cast and Ensemble X, with whom Wallen regularly collaborates, to create something well-timed, poignant and hugely enjoyable. Attention didn’t waver in the tightly packed 80 minutes. Though the production values were evidently high and the direction thorough, there were moments when the balance between musicians and singers saw some of the detail in the text waver; the lasting effect was one of a stylishly sophisticated end-of-term nativity that brought a group of strangers together in celebration of something new.

Its premiere the night before in Orford Church – the same church where Britten’s community opera Noye’s Fludde received its premiere back in 1958 – was no coincidence, nor is its arrival in the year marking 50 years since the composer’s death. The considerable resources honoured Britten’s legacy with something both fresh and timeless.
It’s not an easy undertaking. Workshopped with the local community since May (and 18 months before that with professional cast members), Wallen’s score is carefully pitched for young voices, amateur singers, and professionals. There’s a whiff of Britten-esque darkness in the Master of the King’s Music’s musical language that hints at a sense of heartwarming continuity, though Wallen’s approach softens the hard-edged awkwardness often found in Britten’s text setting. Indeed, her transitions into the congregational carols are masterful, so much so that nearly all of them crept up on us by surprise.
The surprise is Wallen’s craft; clearer diction would have let us hear the carols coming. Nick Mercer as a mildly grotesque Preco brought energy to the stage, though the detail of the call to the audience, rehearsed before the performance got underway, was lost. The balance issues also cropped up in other solo lines at various points, most notably in Andrew Watts’s solo lines as Herod in Scene 3. Diction aside, the melodic line was capitalised on by the countertenor, whose shrill characterisation of a maniacal authoritarian moved this telling of the Christmas story away from fluffy sheep and pantomime villains towards something appropriately a little edgier. That said, we did boo Herod when Watts appeared for his curtain call. How could we not?

In stark contrast, Mary’s aria, sung by Angela Tait, was a tender expression of vulnerability, an oasis amid the miracle and the promised violence. As in Britten’s community operas, the relatability of Wallen’s solo Mary was the consequence of her not being a professional singer. Indeed, depicting the birth in shadow play, subsequently cut with strategic calls from sheep at the back of the church, and an eerie adult chorus cue avoided romanticising the core of the story.

Angela Tait’s demure Mary was a well-judged contrast to Andrew Watts’s camp, sometimes piercing, villainous Herod. A considerable flock of shepherds partied hard before demonstrating genuine shock at the appearance of the Angel Gabriel. Ox, ass and field mice, enhanced by exquisite wicker animal heads, brought mute character to proceedings too. In this way, the production worked not only because the score was made for its company, but also because the direction capitalised on it. Wake-Walker and the team of producers, directors and designers made full use of every opportunity. Rarely has the arrival of so many Magi in luxurious costumes brought so much colour to a space. This, like the shepherds’ Nordic winter hues, contrasted well with the Angel Gabriel’s soft white cloak with its jaunty right-angle cuts. Like the costume design, the lighting not only made use of the low sun streaming through the church windows at the start of the performance but also created drama when Herod was led to whatever was waiting for him beyond the red light, outside the west door.

In the programme, director Frederic Wake-Walker positioned A Christmas Miracle as a call to unite against the forces of ideology, division, and disconnection. Whether it’s the production itself that achieves this, or the printed provocation, is up for debate. The idea certainly lingers in the mind long after the audience have left the church. A Christmas Miracle is an uplifting setting. A product of the community it’s produced by. A bid for community too.
A Christmas Miracle heads to Orkney for performances on 4 and 5 December at St Magnus Cathedral.