20 things from ABO 2023

I haven’t attended a useful conference for a long time – usefulness meaning timely storytelling, insights that make me want to reach for my notebook, and thought-provoking questions. I’ll feel I’ve got value for money if on the return journey my reflections lead me further into a subject.

The ABO conference has certainly met these fairly low-level requirements. Those presentations built on data explaining audience behaviours provided something tangible, in turn highlighting how easy it is to get lost in aspiration. Those that were low on content and big on personality were a comparatively empty experience. I’ve captured some of the things I found myself responding to in a list at the end of this post.

What dominates my thoughts heading home is how I’ve heard a lot of people talking about the classical music ‘experience’ in a bid to illustrate that an individual’s love of live music consisted of more than what was going on in the auditorium. Where that experience begins – on the journey to the venue, as you walk through the doorway, or when you obtain your pre-concert drink – is up for debate, but its good to see people in the industry beginning to make the obvious a little more explicit.

A few snippets from various events that really stuck in my mind:

  1. “We need to articulate the way music connects with humanity.”
  2. Music plays a critical role in the well-being of society.
  3. How do we tell the most compelling story to the widest possible audience?
  4. Audience behaviour has been negatively impacted by the cost of living crisis.
  5. UK orchestras contributed £4 billion to the UK economy in 2021.
  6. 4 million people enjoyed 3600 concerts across the UK in 2021.
  7. It’s possible to measure someone’s emotional response to music through their sweat.
  8. Don’t assume that concert/operagoers also listen to their favourite genre on the radio.
  9. 83% of respondents in a Global Radio survey said they were mindful of the cost of living crisis in their decision-making even if it didn’t noticeably impact them.
  10. According to Global, Classic FM’s listeners are seeking more than just companionship or mood-driven distraction. Listeners are curious and seek opportunities to explore.
  11. Commercial radio listening is up, but listener needs have shifted from companionship to exploration.
  12. How can the industry steepen the curve of older people returning to the concert hall?
  13. Concert-goers habits have changed – some feel travel is effort (hardly surprising)
  14. 22% of respondents in LIVE’s survey showed choice was being made based on artist.
  15. What changes need to be made to formats and access to persuade latent classical fans?
  16. Data gathered by Dr Sarah Price (Liverpool University) reinforces the view that some cultural curious potential concert-goers seek presentation and contextualisation to alleviate perceived disconnect between themselves and regular concert goers. (There’s a book in this, probably.)
  17. (Dr Sarah Price) There remains a significant proportion of the population for whom access to arts institutions is difficult, impossible or even cultural unpalatable.
  18. Is the change in audience behaviour a reflection of the core audience not missing the live experience as much as we all assumed they would?
  19. The ‘still and silent’ concert experience amounts to a small proportion of activities.
  20. Are we here to serve the artform or the audience?

I was especially impressed with Global Radio (Classic FM’s parent company) strong clear messaging post-RAJARs (industry survey into listening habits for those who don’t know of it). Classic dominates the classical radio listening landscape with 5 million weekly listeners, compared to its trying-ever-so-hard competitor Scala Radio at 300K weekly listeners. Radio 3’s 1 million compares well given its product is editorially distinct, but Global highlighting a shift in audience interest towards ‘education’ hints that the BBC’s commercial competitor might be shifting its sights.

2022 / 2023

I’m a little late with the annual review and look ahead this year. There’s a very simple explanation why. When you break from the habit of regular writing so atrophy kicks in. Where a blog post seemed like an inconsequential task three months ago, it now presents itself like a huge hill to climb. 

One way to sum up Thoroughly Good’s 2022 is by using the metaphor of a jigsaw puzzle. The years prior were spent scrabbling around for all of the pieces that weren’t to be found in the box. Progress on the puzzle was very slow up until last August 2020 when following a catastrophic stroke suffered by my mother, work on the jigsaw took on a whole new pace. The past twelve months saw me find the final pieces and fit them into place. After that, I started to look at the picture. It may not have looked very pretty but it did make perfect sense.

Sheffield Chamber Music Festival from Music in the Round

The unexpected consequence of this year was confronting a core belief that had for years before been reasonably useful (if unnecessarily negative). That recurring core belief – both a motivator and a deterrent – is no longer ‘I’m not good enough’. It has been reframed, buffed and polished. I’m now ‘knowledgeable, experienced and capable’ and ready to take the next steps, being far less reactive as I adopt a more proactive role in all aspects of my life.

Bach Brandenburg Concertos at Music at Malling

Music has underscored this period in a profound way. Schubert’s Winterreise is now not so much a daunting must-listen as a sought-after escape made more potent by vivid memories of hearing Ben Appl and James Bailleu perform at Two Moors. The Scottish Chamber Orchestra’s rip-roaring performance of Tchaikovsky’s 6th at Usher Hall in late summer had a hugely energising effect on the senses (in the same concert as James MacMillan’s second violin concerto).

Yuja Wang at Southbank Centre brought an international charge to the Royal Festival Hall. Víkingur Ólafsson’s solo recital at a packed Snape Maltings at Aldeburgh Festival 2022 is another special memory, preceded by Tom Coult’s and Alice Birch’s opera premier ‘Violet’.

Violet premiered at the opening night of the Aldeburgh Festival 2022

Pavel Kolesnikov, Kaleidoscope Chamber Collective, and Manchester Camerata with Jess Gillam at Wigmore Hall all scored very highly in my 2022 journal. And Leif Ove Andsnes at Wigmore Hall was – no exaggeration here – a dream come true. And to wrap up the year, seeing the Philharmonia perform Mahler 6 at Festival Hall seemed to sum up my years of thinking in one epic dollop of music. 

Scottish Chamber Orchestra at Usher Hall

What all of these experiences have in common is the way they injected into my year. They were experiences I recall now has promoting a sense of intense focus. Laser-like perhaps. And here in particular I’m thinking of the Lerici Music Festival in Italy where in the muggy evening heat on the Italian town’s seafront, pianist Christian Blackshaw performed electrifying ly intimate Mozart that made all of us sat on our plastic chairs lead forward attentively. These are lasting impactful experiences that form the core of what I’ve come to understand Thoroughly Good is as a brand – one that seeks out and documents fulfilling connections made with or as a result of music and classical music in particular and puts the audience member at the heart of that experience.

Christian Blackshaw at Lerici Music Festival 2022

Would-be iconoclasts have continued to enrage me these past twelve months. I begin 2023 reminded of a basic fact that innovation doesn’t necessarily guarantee 100% houses, and that existing well-loved brands have to think of their existing subscribers, friends and supporters first if they are to retain their considerable financial contribution. That’s not to say that everyone can rest on their laurels and ignore the need for change. What it reveals for me is the considerable challenge artistic directors face in finding the sweet spot – innovative programming that sells tickets and retains if not increases mid-long-term support. And given the Arts Council NPO furore in the final few months of the year, that challenge is even greater now.

What I’m increasingly drawn to is examining more closely what the present-day classical music experience actually is. I appreciate for example that to-date my experience (appreciative of it as I am) limited to those events in and around London and, if it is further afield as a result of personal invitations. It is a limited experience. What would actively looking further afield in various different nooks and crannies reveal? What are existing audiences experiencing across the country and further afield? Who makes up ‘the classical music audience’ and where do I fit into that as a profile? How does the classical music industry seek to or succeeding in continuing to satisfy what I want as a punter?

Making intentional choices is the first step in pursuit of answers to some of those questions. I’ve already drawn up plans for visits beyond London in the coming months and hope those experiences will form the basis of a new writing project coming up later in 2023. Such active decision-making is of course a natural consequence of that reframed core-belief I mentioned earlier in this post. It’s also incredibly and unexpectedly exciting.

Benjamin Grosvenor (and David Gray’s) Bethlehem Down

A modest post on Facebook from pianist Benjamin Grosvenor and I’m triggered to write. Hear that? That’s the internet collectively sighing.

Grosvenor’s recording of Warlock’s Bethlehem Down arranged by David Gray is a joy. Just enough whimsy, skilfully avoiding sentimentality.

A new addition to the Thoroughly Good Christmas Playlist. That’s confirmed by the way because I’ve played it to The Husband and he confirms that he likes it too.

Lovely work Grosvenor. Got any more?

Anna Lapwood’s new Christmas release: A Pembroke Christmas

Another piece of music which has come as a complete surprise on my gentle trot through new-ish Christmas music this year is that written by baritone Roderick Williams. It appears on Anna Lapwood and Pembroke College Choir’s Christmas release recorded earlier this year.

O Adonai is ten years old, written originally for Ex Cathedra back in 2011/2012, although OUP appears to have marked the copyright as 2004 – so Williams’s creation could be eight years older.

Williams setting of the second O Antiphon is a remarkable creation featuring a mix of solo and groups creating an eerily theatrical feel with the same melodic fragment echoing from the very depths of a cathedral space. At its heart is a central chorus that sings ‘O Lord and Ruler the house of Israel …’ in delectable smooth harmony. Flying around at the top those top voices repeating the opening fragment like birds on the wind.

In the latest recording released on Signum by Anna Lapwood and the Chapel Choir of Pembroke College, Cambridge, the soft smooth sounds of the central chorus combined with the crystal clear lines of the upper voices makes for a reflective experience. I’ve listened to it repeatedly over the past few days.

Another surprise is hearing Emma Johnson’s I Sing of a Maiden featuring the clarinettist in the recording. I adore the apparent simplicity in the initial musical idea. There is a supportive lilt to the entire carol that evokes care and devotion in a tactile way.

The entire album is one of those rare treats (though consistent with all of Lapwood’s recordings) where everything fits the bill musically, but special mention needs to go to The Pembroke College Girls’ Choir themselves for writing an arrangement of Gaudete! which finally lays to rest the to-date persistent memories of Steeleye Span and (by extension) Alan Partridge singing Gaudete. The setting breathes new life into the Christmas cliche.

The girl choristers also composed a setting of Silent Night that started the Christmas album project off in the first place. A ravishing arrangement.

Gavin Sutherland

English National Ballet’s Gavin Sutherland on BBC Radio 3

Gavin Sutherland – conductor of English National Ballet’s Nutcracker was on BBC Radio 3’s In Tune last night. I’ve clipped it up because its a piece of live radio cracking with energy.

Sutherland’s enthusiasm for his is evident in the energy he brings to the conversation, sharing surprising personal anecdotes about his musical background, pointing to Tchaikovsky’s business-minded approach to putting together orchestral suites of ballet music as a way of drawing audiences to the theatre.

The exchange reminds me of how authors wholeheartedly talking about their books can trigger me to purchase their publication simply because of the enthusiasm they bring to their interviews.

English National Ballet’s Nutcracker is at London Coliseum from Thursday 15 December. Book via the English National Opera website.

Benedetti Foundation mounts a £40K fundraiser with a stirring video

Returning to writing about music after a few months away has seen certain activities, brands, issues and discussions come into focus for me. What’s becoming clearer for me is the need to highlight some of the creativity that makes up the UK classical music scene. The Benedetti Foundation fundraiser is one such example.

The music education work led by Nicola Benedetti wears its values on its sleeve. It doesn’t preach. It doesn’t condescend. It doesn’t need to. It has front and centre some one of this country’s finest ambassadors who has herself drawn together the very best in music education specialists – people who facilitate life-changing experiences for all sorts of different people across the world.

That they’ve achieved what they have over the past few years (just look at the video) is a measure of the energy that powers the endeavour. I saw that first-hand at an in-person launch pre-pandemic. The energy in the room was electric. That the Foundation continued its activities throughout the pandemic should be no surprise. Everyone involved has remarkable reserves they draw upon.

The promotional video for the Benedetti Foundation’s current fundraising (they’re in need of an extra £20K to meet their £40K target) is a touching creation too. Clear messaging about the organisation’s purpose, quick cuts, heartfelt first-person endorsements not only from session leaders and teachers, but from participants. The contribution from one woman saying that the work of the Benedetti Foundation had restored her energy for teaching brought a tear to the eye.

Each donation is matched – so a £15 donation resulted in the Benedetti Foundation getting £30. I’m happy to give because I recognise so much of my formative experiences in what the video curates.

Philharmonia’s Carol of the Bells ticks ALL of my boxes

Christmas is underway. The decorations are up at Thoroughly Good HQ. I can smell the approaching holidays. I can’t wait for things to get underway. I know things are tougher this year. Bills will be higher. Things will need to be tightened. Still, for those who pay heed to Christmas, the thought of escape, rest, and reflection gets me all giddy.

The Philharmonia’s 2022 Christmas video is ramping up the emotion too.

A deft piece of marketing featuring musicians from the database coming together to perform an arrangement of Shchedryk, a Ukrainian song celebrating New Year later reworked by composer Peter J. Wilhousky in the 1920s, more commonly known as Carol of the Bells.

The carol is often contextualised as ‘the music from Home Alone’. Given events this year that connection seems facile.

In highlighting the roots of the carol and one of its players connections with it, the Philharmonia have shown solidarity with an ongoing cause. It’s a touching performance, saving the most vulnerable moment right until the end.

An artistic brands relevance isn’t only measured by the number of tickets sold for live concerts. It’s also about how it can illustrate its understanding of the world around it in the content it makes.

Thomas Hewitt Jones charming new carol ‘Love is the Answer’

I’m loving Thomas Hewitt Jones latest carol, Love is the Answer. Published by Stainer & Bell and scored for full choir and organ or piano, THJ’s latest creation is a rosy and uplifting musical expression of kindness. Love is the Answer is packed full of delectable harmonies that evoke a snow-covered hills and brightly lit cottages with wisps of smoke stretching towards the night sky. And that kind of musical indulgence is allowed at Christmas. It’s the law.

Written during the COVID-19 pandemic, this gentle but uplifting feel to the carol was, according to the composer, intended as “an antidote to the gloom, confusion and negativity of that period”.

That same spirit is evident in the promotional video too and points to what I think is Hewitt-Jones particular brand – charm and enthusiasm brimming in every shot most keenly experienced in the stark interior of an office environment. There is a simplicity to the story that makes the emotion of the piece irresistible.

There’s more from THJ later in the month, including a broadcast of the unapologetically perky Holly and the Ivy on 22nd December performed by the BBC Singers.

Love is the Answer is available for SATB choir with organ or piano. Purchase print or download versions via Stainer & Bell.

Ivors Composer Awards 2021 nominees announced

The Ivors Academy have revealed the nominees for classical, jazz and sound art for The Ivors Composer Awards 2021. The winners will be revealed in a live ceremony on 8 December at the British Museum.

In a change with previous years and to reflect the impact the pandemic has had on the music world, The Ivors Academy has included new works on a commercial recording – as long as the recording was the first time the work had been heard by the public – in addition to concerts that were live-streamed anywhere in the world, as long as the concert could be viewed by the UK public.

This year’s nominations include composers such as Tansy Davies, Cheryl Frances-Hoad, Howard Goodall and James MacMillan. 40% of the composers in the running for an Ivor Novello Award this year are first-time nominees, including Nwando Ebizie, Nikki Iles, Dave Manington, Anna Thorvaldsdottir and Alex Paxton, who has three works nominated.

The Ivors Composer Awards are supported by PRS for Music.

JAZZ COMPOSITION


BYE by ALEX PAXTON
for small jazz ensemble and improviser

CORNCRACK DREAMS
by ALEX PAXTON
for trombone, keyboard and drums

DREAMS by BRIGITTE BERAHA and DAVE MANINGTON
for jazz sextet

THE CAGED BIRD by NIKKI ILES
for jazz band

THE RISE OF THE LIZARD PEOPLE by IVO NEAME
for jazz orchestra

LARGE SCALE COMPOSITION


CATAMORPHOSIS by ANNA THORVALDSDOTTIR
for orchestra

DEMOCRACY DANCES by CONOR MITCHELL
for symphony orchestra

KAAMOS by LARA POE
for orchestra

PHARMAKEIA by JAMES DILLON
for 16 players

THIS DEPARTING LANDSCAPE by MARTIN SUCKLING
for orchestra



SMALL CHAMBER COMPOSITION


A FIELD GUIDE TO PEBBLES by LYNNE PLOWMAN
for percussion duo

NIGHTINGALES: ULTRA-DEEP FIELD by TANSY DAVIES
for string quartet

SOMETIMES VOICES by ALEX PAXTON
for keyboard and drums

STILL LIFE by STEPHEN GOSS
for cello and guitar

WICKED PROBLEMS by LAURA BOWLER
for voice, bass flute and fixed tape part

SOLO COMPOSITION
‘ECHO THE ANGELUS’ by JAMES DILLON
for piano

FADING SPELLSPHERE by BEN GAUNT
for piano

LAMPADES by MARTIN IDDON
for tuba and fixed media

LINEAR CONSTRUCTION (NO. 5) by ALEX GROVES
for cello

NO ONE by ROBIN HAIGH
for harp



SOUND ART


FIRE PREVENTION OR HOW TO SING A LABYRINTH OR THE REBEING AND THE BURNING OF THE LABYRINTH by NWANDO EBIZIE
for piano, voice and electronics with field recordings

LONDON 26 AND 28 MARCH 2020: IMITATION: INVERSION by CAROLINE KRAABEL
for baritone, alto and sopranino saxophones and double bass

NOCTURNAL INSIGHTS by NIKKI SHETH
for field recordings of crepuscular and nocturnal wildlife in the UK

THE CUCKMERE SOUNDWALK by ED HUGHES
for chamber orchestra

WAVES OF RESISTANCE (RADIO ART WITHOUT BORDERS) TONNTA FRIOTAÍOCHTA (EALAÍNE RAIDIÓ GAN TEORAINNEACHA) by MAGZ HALL
radiophonic poem, WASP synth and location recordings from the Irish Sea and Canterbury Garden



VOCAL OR CHORAL COMPOSITION


BARUCH – TEN PROPOSITIONS OF BARUCH SPINOZA FOR TENOR AND PIANO by MICHAEL ZEV GORDON
for tenor and piano

GYÖKÉR (ROOT) by THOMAS ADÈS
for mezzo-soprano and four percussionists

NEVER TO FORGET by HOWARDGOODALL
for SATB choir and small orchestra

THINKING I HEAR THEE CALL by CHERYL FRANCES-HOAD
for soprano, speaker and electronics

VIDI AQUAM by JAMESMACMILLAN
for 40 a cappella voices, split into 8 SSATB choirs

National Youth Orchestra bassoonists rock (and pop)

Hats off to the National Youth Orchestra bassoonists this year (and the organisation’s social media bod) for capturing and sharing this cracking arrangement of a Britney Spears ‘Toxic’. Packed full of energy. Funny too.

What really gets me is how this time a year ago there were so many organisations pumping out lockdown videos consisting of isolated musicians. Back then we were marvelling at their isolated togetherness. A year later, we’re marvelling at them in real life.

Uplifting stuff. And there’s more to come, apparently.