On Chalamet and sympathy exhausted

The Chalamet outrage responded to by artists and organisations isn’t the advocacy they think it is. It addresses the already-converted. It’s performance. That performance has a cost: it’s exhausting to witness, and it makes the cause seem more fragile than it is. If Chalamet’s opinion about ballet genuinely threatens ballet (or opera), then both have problems no Instagram post will fix. And it alienates people like me who are actually sympathetic and life-membership advocates.

The arts, at their best, model humility and curiosity. How many of the people responding have seen the long-form version of the interview? Why was that clip made available in that form, at this moment? The answer probably has less to do with ballet or opera’s plight (after all, is Chalamet a credible commentator on the industry’s health?), than with the entertainment industry’s appetite to damage an Oscar campaign. The arts community has been played. Their outrage is someone else’s strategy working exactly as intended. They’re not getting the reach they think they’re getting. They’re shouting into an echo chamber.


← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

  • Review – Philharmonia with Manfred Honeck and Emanuel Ax

    Review – Philharmonia with Manfred Honeck and Emanuel Ax

    Honeck’s first outing as the Philharmonia’s Principal Conductor-in-waiting left a promise of energy, surprise and delight, and perhaps a little healthy rivalry for London’s other orchestras. Manfred Honeck breathed new life into London’s orchestral scene last night at the Royal Festival Hall, summoning long, sweeping lines and an expressive range underpinned by innate awareness and…

  • Review – Marsalis’ All Rise from Edinburgh Festival (Sky Arts)

    Review – Marsalis’ All Rise from Edinburgh Festival (Sky Arts)

    Classical music TV works when it follows the long-established conventions too many are too eager to abandon: play it straight; trust the audience. Sky Arts kicked off a new series of Monday-evening concerts this week, starting with a broadcast of James Gaffigan conducting the Edinburgh International Festival opening concert from August 2026. The first episode…

  • Review – London Mozart Players with Jonathan Bloxham Mozart with Roderick Williams and Sophie Bevan

    Review – London Mozart Players with Jonathan Bloxham Mozart with Roderick Williams and Sophie Bevan

    London Mozart Players say they’re freshest of chamber orchestras. After conductor Jonathan Bloxham’s Mozart Jupiter, “refreshed” looks nearer the mark: a band powered by its strings and infectious enthusiasm, and tested by a boomy acoustic.